Benchmarking: Why do we struggle to measure the impact of L&D?

Benchmarking is a verb, a doing word, an action.

Written by Anna Barnett
Published 05 December 2022
Benchmarking: Why do we struggle to measure the impact of L&D?

This is ironic because those innovative professionals who want to do something are the most likely to engage with benchmarking practices. In 2022, top performing learning organizations were 66 times more likely to use benchmarking as a performance improvement tool than everybody else.

As a process, benchmarking provides organizations, teams and individuals with a clearer understanding of how they’re doing – whether they’re keeping up with their industries, their competitors or the global standard – and the direction they’re moving in. Done right, benchmarking provides professionals with an objective and realistic assessment of progress and an opportunity to reflect on it. For many, it also provides the evidence they need to convince the C-suite that new initiatives are worth the risk or to identify the most effective ways to make use of employee talent.

Measuring impact is a process of discovery

In just two years, the number of L&D leaders with a seat at the executive table has more than doubled. Leaders that have already made it need to retain their seat. Leaders that haven’t need to pull up a pew. The problem, though, is that most L&D teams report too much on learning activity and too little on business impact, when operational metrics mean very little to senior management in comparison.

Impact is a big word and inherently difficult to measure. Considering learning maturity, the least mature organizations are also the least likely to:

  • Measure business metrics when evaluating the effectiveness of learning

  • Communicate performance impacts to senior and line managers

  • Share how learning benefits the business.

Benchmark graph likeliness to measure impact

Traditionally, when organizations think about measuring impact, they think about data. And they’re not wrong to. Statistically speaking, in 2022 data-related analytic skills were the only skills to have a direct impact on the future of learning, and yet they continue to be the least common skills L&D teams have. It’s not the case that organizations don’t know they need them, but demand severely outweighs supply. Only 12% of low-impact learning organizations have analytic capabilities in-house but 98% consider them to be a priority for learning.

But measuring impact is bigger than spreadsheets and statistics. It’s about understanding your strengths, your gaps and your direction. It’s a process of discovery, where you ask bolder questions like:

  • What have we achieved in the past year and where do we want to be in 12 months from now?

  • How closely do our behaviors align with our priorities?

  • Which barriers restrict us from reaching our potential?

  • What can we learn from other, more successful organizations?

How can benchmarking transform your L&D strategy?

Every year the demand on L&D grows exponentially. In 2022, "L&D being overwhelmed and under-equipped" was reported as one of the most significant barriers to organizational learning, second only to "managers being reluctant to make time". [1] Constantly, L&D find themselves involved in new areas of the business, firefighting new challenges, and feeling responsible for more than they bargained for. The same strategy, no matter how successful in the past, won’t cut it year after year – the goalposts are moving too quickly.

Benchmark graph Top 5 challenges faced by L&D

Each year, around 10% of L&D teams set the benchmark for success. These ‘top performers’ (as we call them) are two to three time more likely to report a reduction in employee turnover, an increase in organizational productivity, and an increase in organizational revenue. But they’re not immune to the challenge of keeping up. If anything, sustaining success can be harder than attaining it, and so all organizations, regardless of learning maturity, have a responsibility to keep their finger on the pulse. Because success looks different every year, it’s essential to benchmark your learning strategy regularly. Those that do tend to improve each time they return. On average, more than half of organizations that repeatedly benchmark experience measurable improvements.

By definition, the very purpose of benchmarking is to compare. To compare your achievements, your struggles, your behaviors, and to do so in a way that shows you, through data, how far you are from organizations that are getting things right. Through benchmarking, you establish areas of focus, things to celebrate, and future challenges. The process gives you the clarity you’ll need to begin closing the gap between you and top performers.

Advance your L&D strategy in 2023 – Get started today!

Perhaps most surprisingly, top performing learning organizations spend the least on L&D. Compared with all other organizations, top performers save an average of £100 per employee. They’re making smarter decisions – like the decision to benchmark for free – which are cost effective in the long term.

The Learning Performance Benchmark tool is free, independent and confidential. The tool has calculated what top performing organizations look like, what they prioritize, and how they behave. How do you compare?


[1] 2022 Annual L&D Benchmark report, Is your learning culture keeping pace with rapid digitalization? [Available here]


About the author

Anna Barnett

Anna Barnett

With a strong background in academic research, Anna completed her PhD in 2020 and is now a core member of our Impact & Insights team. Anna specializes in producing high-quality, comprehensive and topical evidence-based reports for the L&D community.

You may also be interested in…

How can learning support the financial industry?

Banks and financial services have had to become increasingly resilient in the face of volatile market pressures. First the pandemic. Now inflation, war, rising interest rates and supply chain pressures mean that financial organizations have had to become smarter than ever to survive.

March 2023

Read More

How can managers help retain top talent?

Discover some important insights from our 2022 Annual L&D Benchmark Report.

August 2022

Read More

How important are managers to learning?

Discover some important insights from our latest Learner Intelligence Report.

July 2022

Read More